Razor burn is one of the worst results of shaving. It’s characterized as painful, irritating red rash, oftentimes with small, red bumps. To soothe skin from razor burn, after shave lotions, balms, colognes, or liquids are often applied. The most common ingredients found in such after shave products are aloe vera and witch hazel. In today’s list of most recommended products for men’s skincare 2020, we’re counting down the top rated aftershave for all skin types.
Best Rated Affordable Aftershave (Everything $20 and Below!)
1. Proraso After Shave Lotion, Refreshing and Toning, 3.4 Fl Oz
Complete the shaving process with this much-loved after shave lotion from Proraso. It features a cool, freshing, and toning formula that features witch hazel, known to reduce inflammation and promote skin healing. It also contains menthol to revitalize and cool the skin and eucalyptus oil to purify skin. 98% of ingredients in this Proraso after shave lotion have natural origins. This product does not contain parabens, phthalates, silicones, mineral oils, artificial colors or sodium laurel sulfate. The Proraso brand was founded in 1908 by Ludovico Martelli in Italy and since 1948 has provided professional, quality products that provide a pleasurable shave. This product is rated 4.6 out of 5 by customers on Amazon.
Promising review: “Great aftershave to combine with Proraso soap. It has a light burn and gives a mentholated feeling similar to after brushing your teeth. Smells really fantastic but not overpowering, old school cool like something your grandpa used to wear. I have medium sensitive skin and this aftershave definitely calms it down. Combine this with a lotion because it’s on the thin side, but you should really be using a light lotion after shaving anyway.” Bradley Z.
2. Face of Danger Organic After Shave Elixir Lotion
From Fieldworks Supply Company comes this organic after shave lotion called Face of Danger, specifically designed for sensitive skin. It has a naturally antibacterial and antiseptic formula made of a unique blend of herbs and essential oils that together calms and heals post-shave skin. The secret to its organic formula is calendula, witch hazel, and vetiver, which together increase circulation on the skin and closes pores, leaving skin cool and refreshed. It also has aloe vera and nutmeg to moisturize and soothe skin. Lastly, bentonite clay helps heal and remove toxins from the skin. This product does not contain alcohol so it does not sting or irritate. Customers rated this product 4.1 out of 5 on Amazon.
Promising review: “This is one of the products that actually helps against razor bumps. I used to get them bad. Since I started using this product, I have not been getting those annoying razor bumps. I recommend this product to anyone.” Byron L. Hunter
3. Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel
Razor burn can cause painful, irritating ingrown hairs. Prevent this by applying Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel, which features a smooth, fragrance-free, alcohol-free formula. Powered by PureScience, its formula harnesses natural ingredients for their anti-inflammatory benefits to help calm and hydrate post-shave skin. It contains aloe leaf juice to calm, soothe, and soften, sage, lavender, and rosemary for its antioxidants, vitamins, healing properties, and aroma, chamomile to reduce redness and irritation, and balm mint for its antioxidants and damage-prevention. Customers rated this product 4.6 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Promising review: “Got this for my boyfriend after reading the reviews. He used to wear the cheap aftershave and I surprised him with this. He fell in love with it and still talks about how great it is everytime he uses it. He loves the cooling effect it gives his face and the way it smells. It’s not too oily or gooey but gives the perfect amount of moisture. Will buy from now on!” Vanessa Mendez
4. Viking Revolution Sandalwood After-Shave Balm
Start a revolution against razor burn with this after-shave balm from Viking Revolution. Crafted with a premium combination of natural ingredients, this after-shave balm is specifically designed for all skin types, including sensitive skin. Customers rated this product 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Promising review: “This product contains all natural ingredients, and I have acne type skin and it has not caused any problems so far. Olive oil has natural antibacterial properties. I also have a sensitive nose, and the sandalwood scent is not overpowering, so it is good for me. Similar products have petroleum derivatives, like the polysorbate-80, which this product does not contain, and the polysorbate does cause my skin to break out. This is also a good value for the money comparing to facial moisturizers, and I will be using this product for a long time.” C. Wheatley
5. Lather & Wood Shaving Co. Ultra-Soothing After-shave Balm
Razor burn is a common problem after shaving. Thankfully, there’s Lather & Wood’s after-shave balm that has a non-drying formula which targets razor burn and calms irritation. This moisturizing balm goes on nice and smooth with its non-greasy hydrating formula that easily absorbs into the skin. Customers rated this product 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Promising review: “I will never go back to traditional aftershave products again. I love the moisturizing capabilities and have gotten many compliments on the scent and feel of my skin after using.” Joe Mantel
More Best-rated Men’s Skincare 2020 Options for All Skin Types
1. Pre de Provence After Shave Balm
Especially formulated to help soothe skin irritation, Pre de Provence After Shave Balm is packed with skin-loving ingredients such as shea oil and grape skin that both hydrate and smooth skin. It also contains aloe vera and allantoin, known for its skin healing properties. Pre de Provence provides an aromatic, warm, and spicy scent that is peppery with a citrus top note, combined with cedar wood, juicy plum and violet leaves that’s held together by an ambery base of leather and tobacco. Customers rated this product 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Promising review: “I have very sensitive skin prone to razor burn. So far only this balm has helped and keeps my 40+ year old face from burning. It also has a wonderful scent. Nice and light, not overpowering. I got compliments from female coworkers who don’t normally do that kind of thing.” One Soldier
2. Era Organics Aftershave Shave Serum
Era Organics offers the same high quality products for men with this shave serum. It features a robust formula that’s packed with ginger, burdock root, black walnut and white oak bark extract. This all-in-one formula effectively exfoliates to help prevent ingrown hairs and works as a gentle astringent to help fight blemishes and acne. It provides deep hydration and extra nourishing for better post-shave skin. Customers rated this product 4.1 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Promising review: “My husband and I both use this product. It helps a lot with soothing both the skin on his face and the skin on my legs. We don’t normally share products lol, but this works so good, so he wanted me to try it. The smell is nice, it’s not my favorite, but it’s fine because I love how it works. I don’t really get razor burn anymore and any bumps after I shave. My husbands face looks smoother and he also no longer gets razor burn.” Tamayo1
3. American Shaving Co. After Shave Balm, Sandalwood Scent
Sometimes, all you need is a basic product that truly delivers. This men’s after-shave balm from American Shaving Co. provides immediate relief after shaving with its gentle, protective, and hydrating formula. It replenishes moisture on the skin with its fast-absorbing, alcohol-free formula that calms irritated skin. It also features a woodsy, robust sandalwood scent that is earthy and bold, providing a timeless, manly appeal. Customers rated this 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Promising review: “This is exactly what I’ve been looking for. I don’t have super sensitive skin but it’s hard to find a good after shave that really feels good and a scent that actually smells the way it’s advertised. This really is the old school barber shop smell. For a good price, you get a good volume of it that will last a while.” Darren Creech
4. Brickell Men’s Instant Relief Aftershave
Never travel without this again: Brickell Men’s Instant Relief Aftershave comes in a travel-friendly size so you can fight skin irritation wherever you are. Brickell offers a formula that is packed with natural ingredients such as aloe vera, lavender, vitamin E, and sugar cane. Its botanical extracts repair skin and combats bacteria to prevent irritation and ingrown hair. It also contains natural hydrators in its alcohol-free formula. Customers rated this 4.6 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Promising review: “You’ll feel it getting to work as soon as you put it on. I could never shave against the grain before as it left bumps and burning sensation. But with this I never have to worry about any of that. This is the best after shave I have ever used.” Moosa R.
5. Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Aftershave
Crafted with safe, natural, and organic ingredients, Pacific Shaving Company Caffeinated Aftershave is powered by antioxidant-rich, naturally-derived caffeine to provide an exceptional shave. It helps reduce the appearance of redness and irritation. Its unique formula is packed with aloe and spearmint essential oil and is made with no synthetic fragrances. It comes in a TSA-friendly container so you can battle post-shave irritation anywhere. A little goes a long way, too! Customers rated this 4.6 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Promising review: “Feels great after a shave. Really thick and a little goes a long way. Helps with irritation and leaves my face feeling good all day everyday.” Tim
Men’s Skincare 2020: Luxury Aftershave Picks
1. DIOR Sauvage After Shave Balm
For high maintenance men who only want luxurious products to touch their skin, consider the Dior Sauvage After Shave Balm, a non-oily balm that features an indulgent texture that quickly penetrates for instant soothing. It features a subtle Sauvage fragrance familiar to most Dior lovers. Sauvage features only natural ingredients, with top notes bursting with the juicy freshness of Reggio di Calabria bergamot. It also features Ambroxan that is derived from ambergris for a manly, woody whiff. It’s all held together by Sichuan Pepper for a truly raw and noble style. Rated 5 out of 5 stars at Sephora.
Promising review: “I bought this for my husband and he is in love with it. He doesn’t wear much cologne but this one, Versace Eros and the Coach for Men are his top three. This scent is seductive and masculine. I love it. I bought the set. This does make your skin soft. Wife approved.” Nicolesecret
2. TOM FORD Noir After Shave Balm
The Tom Ford Noir fragrance is at the center of this intensely rich balm that effectively hydrates and helps soothe dry, just-shaven skin. The Tom Ford Noir is a fragrance that’s sensual, perfectly capturing through a fragrance the duality of the refined, urbane sophisticate and the intriguingly sensuous, private man to the ones closest to him. This luxurious after shave is a portrait of elegance and edge, thanks to its notes of Bergamot, Violet Flower, Tuscan Iris, Black Pepper Oil, Benzoin Resin, Opoponax. Be that man who is refined, sophisticated, and intriguing with this unique fragrance from Tom Ford. Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars at Sephora.
Promising review: “Smells and goes on like a dream. A penny-sized amount is enough to cover my face and neck, and the powder-y finish means I don’t feel oily or slick. Pairs seamlessly with the Noir deodorant and fragrance. Just one demerit: This after shave doesn’t clear up all redness or dry all razor nicks, but you can’t really get that kind of performance out of a balm. This is more of a soother, and for most guys, that’s enough.” Salvolatile
3. HERMÈS Terre d’Hermès After-Shave Balm
Hermès has long been synonymous with opulent, modern style. Experience the same luxurious style with the Terre d’Hermès After-Shave Balm, which hydrates and comforts newly shaved skin with its subtle scent of Terre d’Hermès. It comes in a light, fluid formula with a non-greasy texture that’s easily applied and absorbed by the skin. It features grapefruit, woody notes, mineral notes, and green notes. It exudes a woody, vegetal, and mineral style. Rated 5 out of 5 stars at Sephora.
Promising review: “Bought it for my boyfriend. And he loves it. It’s so hard to let guys do their skin care routine, but he kept using it every single day. It must be good! It makes a difference, the face gets smooth after shave and the scent is just perfect.” Gghhjkl
4. ARMANI BEAUTY Armani Code After Shave Lotion
This fresh, sexy, masculine after shave lotion from Armani Beauty is seductive as it is stylish. It features a blend of fresh lemon and bergamot, peppered with some orange tree blossom and topped with soothing guaiac wood, and tonka bean. It features unforgettable Mediterranean notes that you’ll love to smell every day. Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars at Sephora.
Promising review: “The only perfume he would wear. He’s been using this scent for decades. I will get him a gift set of this perfume even his new one is still full.” MyBeautyDiary
5. ARMANI BEAUTY Acqua Di Gio Pour Homme After Shave Lotion
Born from nature, the Acqua Di Gio Pour Homme After Shave Lotion from Armani Beauty is inspired by the sea, sun, earth, and breeze of a far off Mediterranean island. It features a transparent, aromatic, and woody scent that exudes masculinity in a perfect blend of marine notes, fruits, herbs, and woods. It features notes of mandarin, bergamot, neroli, persimmon, rosemary, nasturtium, jasmine, amber, patchouli, and cistus. Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars at Sephora.
Promising review: “Smells great. The scent of this is lighter than that of the cologne, but it smells fresh and has good staying power. I got this for me to enjoy just as much as I got it for him. Warning: this is not a lotion; it is a liquid (alcohol) aftershave, but I knew that before purchasing, so this is exactly what I was looking for.” Lizzardm84
More great deals on skincare and health products for men await in the links from our archive below. Make sure to bookmark The Teelie Blog for daily recommendations on the best products on the market today.
Just a disclaimer – We have partnered with these companies because we use their products and/or proudly trust and endorse them – so we do receive a commission if you make a purchase or sign up for services. Often, we are able to negotiate special discounts and/or bonuses, which we will pass on to you via our links. We often get short notice on sale items available for 24-48 hours as we will pass these savings onto you.